The Missing Link - a lost fic
Feb. 22nd, 2010 01:41 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
therealsnapeWhile I was commenting on a journal entry of ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
tetleythesecond today, I wanted to link to this story and found I never posted it.It's an old one, written in the summer of 2009 for, I think, a ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
rarepair_shorts fest, a very low-pressure, post-if-you-wish sort of thing. Someone gave a Snape/Minerva pairing with this song as a prompt.
In times of war, one loses friends. One is prepared, in an unprepared way.
Sirius. A dreadful shock. Even more since she was standing, or rather, tottering on the side-line at the time. Still. One of the surprising things was that it didn’t happen before. De mortibus nil nisi bene, but one can judge one’s former students analytically. Never one for safe living, Sirius. Be that as it may, for weeks, she winces when Animagi are mentioned.
Alastor. His safety-awareness was a by-word. A joke. It couldn’t happen to him. Another scar, another limb even. Yes. But this. So many shared memories. So many shared drinks. For months, she winces when pouring a Single Malt.
Yet life goes on. That’s more than a platitude. It’s a painful fact. "Life will never be the same," they said. But it is. Daily life goes on, and however much she misses Alastor, he was not a part of daily life. Hours, days go by without being reminded of him. Therefore, without thinking of him.
Then it happens. One loses a friend who was part of daily life. Every hour brings a memory. It’s like having a bruise on the soul. A bruise that is regularly kicked. She winces. Incessantly.
***
Minerva McGonagall broke the seal on the last letter in her in-tray. She quickly perused it. Molly Weasley’s ecstatic comments on Bill’s wedding. What it lacked in punctuation and coherence it more than made up in exclamation marks.
She glanced at the photograph Molly had included. Fleur was predictably stunning. Bill had that look of blissful happiness that made men resemble sheep. Molly, Arthur, and various assorted Weasleys smiled maniacally and waved. Ginny glared resentfully at the frills on her bridesmaid’s dress. Muriel’s face made Minerva wish that someone, somewhere, had hurried up inventing pictures that talked as well as moved.
Fred and George looked impishly and could, at last, be identified because of the ear. Or rather the lack thereof.
The ear.
She winced.
Molly had raved and ranted and made all sorts of accusations. Understandably. Even the most level-headed of mothers would dislike the wizard who cut off her son’s ear. When Molly had accused Severus of secretly desiring his male students and of taking revenge on George because he “was a wholesome boy who wouldn’t look twice at the greasy git” she had, briefly, defended him, pointing out among other things that Albus himself trusted him.
The ensuing monologue had included every possible cliché. Blind faith in Albus, understandable after such a close, close collaboration. And so difficult to forget about work, isn’t it, dear, when there’s no home life to return to. No one doubts your devotion to your students, such a wonderful compensation… Yet a mother’s heart … Well, it’s not exactly something you can explain to people who have no children of their own, but a mother’s heart …
Later that week, over a bottle of Burgundy, Severus had thanked her for standing up for him. And had told her she shouldn’t have; of course he had. She had pointed out that animosity in the Order endangered their work; that Molly was a fool indeed, but that it was no reason to let her turn into a slanderous fool. Who, moreover, could harm Hogwarts’s reputation. And that friends did stand up for each other. At that, Severus had drained his glass with a speed the Burgundy didn’t deserve.
She winced.
The ensuing coldness on Molly’s part had been replaced by a much harder to bear hint of smugness after Albus’s death. And an almost intolerable desire to comfort the poor, bereft, Acting Headmistress.
The wedding invitation had been accompanied by a note pointing out that it would do Minerva all the good in the world to get among other people once more; that it wouldn’t do to dwell on the past; that Albus would have wanted her to attend (but then, she had gone against his wishes often enough); that the company of friends was so vital to someone who had to lead the, let’s face it, dear, somewhat restricted life of an unmarried teacher. Which was a very admirable thing to be, let that be clear! She, Molly, couldn’t do it for all the tea in China.
Minerva had been pleased with that note. It had given her the first real, long laugh of that summer. Together with Poppy who, for the past twenty-seven years, had joyfully shared her pitiful, restricted spinster’s life. And she had sent a handsome gift. Poppy would enjoy this letter. So would …
She winced.
There was still work to do. She checked the in-tray. It really was empty. She looked under it, checked her desk, then the floor, feeling faintly ridiculous while doing so. No other letter. Augusta Longbottom really hadn’t written this year. The letter she had send Augusta on Neville’s choice of N.E.W.T.’s and Augusta’s prejudices, with some fondly recalled and carefully phrased memories on their own N.E.W.T.’s year and their respective results in Charms, seemed to have done the trick. So that was one bet she’d won! Gryffindor leads! A brief spurt of glee, replaced by a piercing sense of reality.
She winced.
She picked up the last letter. Muggle writing paper.
And so I say, if Roderick wants to take this Charming Class, not that he needs it, he always was the most charming boy and I don’t see why we normal folks shouldn’t be able to judge that, then he should be allowed to take it. Regardless of those GCSE’s or Owls or Frogs or whatever you call them. In fact, you should be glad that he even wants to take it.
So I expect to hear that he will be admitted.
Yours truly,
Jane Mainwaring (Mother of Roderick Mainwaring)
Professor McGonagall smiled as she put the letter on the ‘wine’ pile.
She winced.
There was no ‘wine’ pile, just an empty space on her desk. She transferred the paper to ‘answered’. The ‘wine’ pile was history. Ancient, ongoing history.
She picked up the Muggle parent’s letter again. An amusing request was an amusing request, regardless of the number of people around to enjoy it. She wished she could read it to Poppy. But parents’ letters were confidential, restricted to the Headmaster, the Deputy and the Heads of House. So she couldn’t share the funny bits or gossip over them, not anymore.
She winced.
Last year …
***
"I’m tempted to grant this one," she had said, before reading the letter out loud.
And he only has to touch a cauldron to achieve magic. Why, he managed to get egg on four kitchen walls and the ceiling, just by putting it in boiling water.
"He’s obviously a natural. Perhaps you should reconsider him for your N.E.W.T.’s class."
Minerva grinned. Snape checked the look in her eyes and, reassured, grinned back.
"Even in the Muggle world ‘couldn’t boil an egg’ is verging on the negative. And that fool should be burnt with his own cauldron and buried with a wand through his heart. In fact, if I could be certain that he’d be the only casualty, I’d be glad to have him in my N.E.W.T.’s class. I’d be doing the wizarding world a service. Merlins are awarded for less."
Snape had poured Minerva another glass, and then filled his own.
"Here, have a look at this one," she had said. "It seems we have the new Greatest Seer of All Times in our midst. Her parents claim that Sybill is too earth-bound to realize her potential, which is why the poor girl failed her O.W.L."
"Rejected by Sybill? Could anyone wish for a better recommendation?" And they had laughed and raised their glasses to each other.
***
For one brief moment, she allowed herself her memories of their friendship. Truth be told I miss you, she thought. Truth be told I'm lying. I can’t even miss you properly. Not after what you did.
Tomorrow, she would meet with the new Headmaster. She would inform him of the time schedules for the N.E.W.T. students. She would briefly summarize the parents’ requests and her answers. She would not avoid his eyes. He would not avoid Albus’s portrait; it was not like him to do so. When you see his face, I hope it gives you hell, she thought. But she couldn’t be sure, not even of that.
tetleythesecond today, I wanted to link to this story and found I never posted it.It's an old one, written in the summer of 2009 for, I think, a rarepair_shorts fest, a very low-pressure, post-if-you-wish sort of thing. Someone gave a Snape/Minerva pairing with this song as a prompt.In times of war, one loses friends. One is prepared, in an unprepared way.
Sirius. A dreadful shock. Even more since she was standing, or rather, tottering on the side-line at the time. Still. One of the surprising things was that it didn’t happen before. De mortibus nil nisi bene, but one can judge one’s former students analytically. Never one for safe living, Sirius. Be that as it may, for weeks, she winces when Animagi are mentioned.
Alastor. His safety-awareness was a by-word. A joke. It couldn’t happen to him. Another scar, another limb even. Yes. But this. So many shared memories. So many shared drinks. For months, she winces when pouring a Single Malt.
Yet life goes on. That’s more than a platitude. It’s a painful fact. "Life will never be the same," they said. But it is. Daily life goes on, and however much she misses Alastor, he was not a part of daily life. Hours, days go by without being reminded of him. Therefore, without thinking of him.
Then it happens. One loses a friend who was part of daily life. Every hour brings a memory. It’s like having a bruise on the soul. A bruise that is regularly kicked. She winces. Incessantly.
***
Minerva McGonagall broke the seal on the last letter in her in-tray. She quickly perused it. Molly Weasley’s ecstatic comments on Bill’s wedding. What it lacked in punctuation and coherence it more than made up in exclamation marks.
She glanced at the photograph Molly had included. Fleur was predictably stunning. Bill had that look of blissful happiness that made men resemble sheep. Molly, Arthur, and various assorted Weasleys smiled maniacally and waved. Ginny glared resentfully at the frills on her bridesmaid’s dress. Muriel’s face made Minerva wish that someone, somewhere, had hurried up inventing pictures that talked as well as moved.
Fred and George looked impishly and could, at last, be identified because of the ear. Or rather the lack thereof.
The ear.
She winced.
Molly had raved and ranted and made all sorts of accusations. Understandably. Even the most level-headed of mothers would dislike the wizard who cut off her son’s ear. When Molly had accused Severus of secretly desiring his male students and of taking revenge on George because he “was a wholesome boy who wouldn’t look twice at the greasy git” she had, briefly, defended him, pointing out among other things that Albus himself trusted him.
The ensuing monologue had included every possible cliché. Blind faith in Albus, understandable after such a close, close collaboration. And so difficult to forget about work, isn’t it, dear, when there’s no home life to return to. No one doubts your devotion to your students, such a wonderful compensation… Yet a mother’s heart … Well, it’s not exactly something you can explain to people who have no children of their own, but a mother’s heart …
Later that week, over a bottle of Burgundy, Severus had thanked her for standing up for him. And had told her she shouldn’t have; of course he had. She had pointed out that animosity in the Order endangered their work; that Molly was a fool indeed, but that it was no reason to let her turn into a slanderous fool. Who, moreover, could harm Hogwarts’s reputation. And that friends did stand up for each other. At that, Severus had drained his glass with a speed the Burgundy didn’t deserve.
She winced.
The ensuing coldness on Molly’s part had been replaced by a much harder to bear hint of smugness after Albus’s death. And an almost intolerable desire to comfort the poor, bereft, Acting Headmistress.
The wedding invitation had been accompanied by a note pointing out that it would do Minerva all the good in the world to get among other people once more; that it wouldn’t do to dwell on the past; that Albus would have wanted her to attend (but then, she had gone against his wishes often enough); that the company of friends was so vital to someone who had to lead the, let’s face it, dear, somewhat restricted life of an unmarried teacher. Which was a very admirable thing to be, let that be clear! She, Molly, couldn’t do it for all the tea in China.
Minerva had been pleased with that note. It had given her the first real, long laugh of that summer. Together with Poppy who, for the past twenty-seven years, had joyfully shared her pitiful, restricted spinster’s life. And she had sent a handsome gift. Poppy would enjoy this letter. So would …
She winced.
There was still work to do. She checked the in-tray. It really was empty. She looked under it, checked her desk, then the floor, feeling faintly ridiculous while doing so. No other letter. Augusta Longbottom really hadn’t written this year. The letter she had send Augusta on Neville’s choice of N.E.W.T.’s and Augusta’s prejudices, with some fondly recalled and carefully phrased memories on their own N.E.W.T.’s year and their respective results in Charms, seemed to have done the trick. So that was one bet she’d won! Gryffindor leads! A brief spurt of glee, replaced by a piercing sense of reality.
She winced.
She picked up the last letter. Muggle writing paper.
And so I say, if Roderick wants to take this Charming Class, not that he needs it, he always was the most charming boy and I don’t see why we normal folks shouldn’t be able to judge that, then he should be allowed to take it. Regardless of those GCSE’s or Owls or Frogs or whatever you call them. In fact, you should be glad that he even wants to take it.
So I expect to hear that he will be admitted.
Yours truly,
Jane Mainwaring (Mother of Roderick Mainwaring)
Professor McGonagall smiled as she put the letter on the ‘wine’ pile.
She winced.
There was no ‘wine’ pile, just an empty space on her desk. She transferred the paper to ‘answered’. The ‘wine’ pile was history. Ancient, ongoing history.
She picked up the Muggle parent’s letter again. An amusing request was an amusing request, regardless of the number of people around to enjoy it. She wished she could read it to Poppy. But parents’ letters were confidential, restricted to the Headmaster, the Deputy and the Heads of House. So she couldn’t share the funny bits or gossip over them, not anymore.
She winced.
Last year …
***
"I’m tempted to grant this one," she had said, before reading the letter out loud.
And he only has to touch a cauldron to achieve magic. Why, he managed to get egg on four kitchen walls and the ceiling, just by putting it in boiling water.
"He’s obviously a natural. Perhaps you should reconsider him for your N.E.W.T.’s class."
Minerva grinned. Snape checked the look in her eyes and, reassured, grinned back.
"Even in the Muggle world ‘couldn’t boil an egg’ is verging on the negative. And that fool should be burnt with his own cauldron and buried with a wand through his heart. In fact, if I could be certain that he’d be the only casualty, I’d be glad to have him in my N.E.W.T.’s class. I’d be doing the wizarding world a service. Merlins are awarded for less."
Snape had poured Minerva another glass, and then filled his own.
"Here, have a look at this one," she had said. "It seems we have the new Greatest Seer of All Times in our midst. Her parents claim that Sybill is too earth-bound to realize her potential, which is why the poor girl failed her O.W.L."
"Rejected by Sybill? Could anyone wish for a better recommendation?" And they had laughed and raised their glasses to each other.
***
For one brief moment, she allowed herself her memories of their friendship. Truth be told I miss you, she thought. Truth be told I'm lying. I can’t even miss you properly. Not after what you did.
Tomorrow, she would meet with the new Headmaster. She would inform him of the time schedules for the N.E.W.T. students. She would briefly summarize the parents’ requests and her answers. She would not avoid his eyes. He would not avoid Albus’s portrait; it was not like him to do so. When you see his face, I hope it gives you hell, she thought. But she couldn’t be sure, not even of that.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 02:16 pm (UTC)And certainly people other than Snape suffered because of his role in the story, and I do think it likely that he and Minerva would have found common ground in appreciating the demands of the dunderheads.
I'm glad that you found this and put it up,
L
(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 02:29 pm (UTC)I must say that I'm quite partial to a bit of Molly bashing in my stories - she really gets on my nerves.
(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 07:14 pm (UTC)Ah, how could I have forgotten... Augusta's letters!
Thank you for re-posting this gem. It's a wonderful mix of sadness, humour and spot-on characterisation of everyone present and not. I love the Ginny cameo!
And I have the distinct feeling that Mrs Mainwaring's letter was inspired by more than one maternal letter-to-the-teacher.
(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 09:32 pm (UTC)Thanks for your review - great as always. You're the first one to remark on Ginny! I seldom write any of the adolescents (apart from that one time when someone
Imperio'edgently asked me to write Luna) and I'm glad you like her.(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 07:45 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 09:33 pm (UTC)Thank you for reviewing. Parents' letters happen to be one of the banes of my RL existence.
(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-22 10:10 pm (UTC)If they're only half as bad as the ones in your story, I can feel your pain. But then, you make excellent use of them here.